Holiday shoppers aren't usually short on options. They're short on time and patience for sorting through them. A strong gift guide can solve that problem directly, turning a crowded catalog into a handful of clear, confident choices. Last Black Friday/Cyber Monday (BFCM) season, 73% of shoppers said they welcome inspiration from retailers when planning gift purchases. A successful gift guide helps shoppers cut through holiday chaos by surfacing items they might otherwise miss, spotlighting your strongest products, and positioning your site as a resource your customers want to return to.

The Starting Point

• Group products by theme, price, or audience to reduce friction
• Spotlight more than your bestsellers to encourage discovery
• Build trust by making your site a go-to holiday resource

Making Guides Work Harder

The strongest guides tell a story. A theme like "Stocking Stuffers Under $25" or "Better-for-You Treats" connects emotionally and makes shopping feel considered rather than transactional.

• Align guides with your brand identity, like "Founder's Favorites"
• Pair guides with supporting content, such as blog posts or recipes, to add context
• Highlight limited-edition or seasonal SKUs to drive urgency

Tips for BFCM Success

• Feature guides prominently in navigation and on the homepage
• Add quick-view or add-to-cart functionality directly on the guide
• Promote guides across email, SMS, and paid ads to maximize reach

Case Study Spotlight

McCormick & Company Simplifies Discovery With Curated Content

For , we restructured navigation and content to make product discovery intuitive. Recipes, collections, and curated pathways helped shoppers connect products to real-life occasions, the same principle that powers a strong gift guide: showing customers exactly what they need, right when they need it.

Cabot Creamery Makes Gifting Simple

‍

For Cabot Creamery, we built out gift guides and product discovery with curated bundles, improved gift card pages, and streamlined cart features like gift messaging and upsells. The result made holiday gifting easier for shoppers from browse to checkout.

Does Your Site Make Gift-Giving Easy?

A gift guide only works as well as the site it lives on. If navigation is cluttered, product pages load slowly, or checkout adds friction, even the best-curated guide will lose shoppers along the way. That's exactly what Val Geisler, our Director of Strategy, and Christine Carforo, our Director of Design, are reviewing during our live site audit on September 23rd ahead of the BFCM code freeze. Submit your site for consideration, and for the chance to win one of five Nintendo Switch 2s and a discounted UX Audit and BFCM Roadmap.

Submissions close September 16th. Submit your site for a teardown.

‍